Lunar sustainability: is it simply more red tape, or a golden opportunity to get things right?

This article is based on a joint publication by the ARC Centre of Excellence in Plants for Space and the Andy Thomas Centre for Space Resources. 

Humans last walked on the surface of the Moon in 1972 as part of the Apollo 17 mission. 

Whilst sustainability was not necessarily an intended focus of the Apollo missions, Apollo 8 astronaut William Anders took the famous Earthrise photo from inside the lunar module. Showing Earth against the backdrop of space, the image illustrates how fragile Earth is, and the responsibility that we have to protect it. 

This in turn helped to launch the first 'Earth Day' and the modern environmental and sustainability movement that followed.

In the next few years, multiple efforts by different countries and private companies (including those of NASA’s Artemis and China’s International Lunar Research Station missions) will return us to the surface of the Moon for the first time in over 50 years. 

When we do finally return, this time it will be to establish a permanent human lunar presence, with early missions laying the foundations for those that follow.

 

Exploring Sustainably

To be able to build a long-term presence on the Moon, we will need to be sustainable – across all aspects of exploration and living. 

Our return to the Moon comes at a time when humanity is faced with a sustainability crisis on Earth. There is an opportunity for our advances in space sustainability to help us address this challenge here on Earth, including the sustainability challenges to Earth's orbit that has become increasingly congested with more satellites and with space junk.

These considerations raise the question: what does it mean to explore space ‘sustainably’, and how can we actually put these ideas into practice?

 

What is lunar sustainability?

‘Sustainability’ in this sense, encompasses environmental protection, economic growth and social responsibility.

Like sustainability on Earth, lunar sustainability goes beyond just reducing material usage and ensuring that recycling exists. 

Achieving sustainability on future lunar missions is a highly interdisciplinary endeavour. Lunar sustainability needs to consider all systems of lunar exploration including agriculture, and transport, as well as the legal and governance aspects. It also needs to facilitate general astronaut well-being, and the need for human communities that will be living and collaborating in space. 

In-Situ Resource Utilisation (ISRU)

Whilst being highly interdisciplinary, acting in a sustainable manner on the Moon has the potential to increase mission safety and success. Using less materials reduces the cost of exploration, and minimising waste generation helps to make the lunar environment safer. 

For humanity to successfully establish a long-term human lunar presence, we’ll need to use the resources that are available on the Moon. This is known as in-situ resource utilisation (ISRU); for example, how water-ice from permanently shadowed craters can provide useful liquid water. 

Lunar sustainability needs to encompass how we use these resources, ensuring that they are used responsibly with a high degree of circularity, and then go beyond ISRU for survival, considering the continued thriving of astronauts through ‘well-being ISRU’. 

Including well-being ISRU as part of an approach to lunar sustainability can provide improvements to mental health, boost innovation and collaboration, and ultimately increase the odds of mission success.

Measuring Progress to Achieve Lunar Sustainability

If lunar sustainability is so interdisciplinary, then what metrics should we use to measure it? 

Measuring sustainability is important because it provides an indicator as to whether we are on track, and identifies areas where improvements are needed.

Considering the different areas that are important to establishing a future long-term human lunar presence, there are different ways in which we could measure sustainability. 

Indicators such as energy performance and material circularity are common measures for engineers. Additionally, to ensure human well-being, social cohesion could be measured through the level of inclusive decision-making. To ensure the longevity of future human lunar presence, agricultural output, supply chain resilience, and legal and governance frameworks can be measured too.

Together, these six metrics provide an opportunity to measure the sustainability of a future human lunar presence.

 

Exploring Space to Improve Life on Earth

Returning to the Moon and establishing a permanent human presence there provides us with the opportunity to re-think the higher sustainability principles that we have here on Earth.

Sustainability in space is not more ‘red-tape’; rather, it is an opportunity to improve mission success, reduce mission costs, and provide insights and a pathway to acting more sustainably here on Earth. Together with all of the other products that the Artemis missions are set to develop that will improve life on Earth, lunar sustainability can too be considered a product of the future Artemis missions.

Despite its scale and size, space is a finite resource – at least the way we’re currently using it. As we return to the Moon, there is a real need to ensure that we protect the space environment for the generations of explorers to come and bring these lessons back to improve life here on Earth.
 

 
ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Tom Cernev is a PhD Candidate at Adelaide University. Together with the ARC Centre of Excellence in Plants for Space and the Andy Thomas Centre for Space Resources, his work explores space resources for long-term human missions and sustainability through the lens of space.

Melissa de Zwart is Professor at Adelaide University and prominent legal researcher working in the areas of commercial and military uses of outer space. She is a member of International Institute of Space Law, and a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Law, a Lieutenant in the Royal Australian Navy (Reserve) and the Deputy Director of Plants for Space.

Volker Hessel is a Professor in the School of Chemical Engineering at Adelaide University. Volker’s track record of transformative industry changes and his dedication to sustainability challenges have provided many life-cycle/cost/circularity/ESG assessments that are used worldwide, helping inform advances in sustainability with Plants for Space.  

Want to learn more? Read the full paper here.